October 2008

Concerns with impact testing | Tech Today

Tech Today not ratednot ratednot ratednot ratednot rated

Concerns with impact testing

Testing may not replicate products' hail-resistance performance

by Mark S. Graham
1 person has posted a comment

In many U.S. regions, the ability of roofing products to resist hail damage is an important performance consideration. Currently, two test methods—UL 2218 and FM 4473—are frequently used to assess products' impact resistances. However, limitations in these test methods may preclude the tests from accurately measuring products' hail-resistance performance.

UL 2218

UL 2218, "Standard for Impact Resistance of Prepared Roof Covering Materials," provides for impact-resistance data for the evaluation of prepared roof covering products. Examples of prepared roof covering products include asphalt, wood, tile, fiber-cement, plastic and metal shingles.

With this standard's test method, a 3- by 3-foot specimen of newly manufactured (nonweathered) roof covering is subjected to impacts from steel balls of varying sizes dropped from specific heights at standard laboratory conditions. The masses of the steel balls combined with the drop heights are said to represent...

To read the article in its entirety, please log in or register (registration is free).

Log in or register for FREE access to this article and other Professional Roofing online content.

Not a professionalroofing.net user?

Register now for free access
  • Full access to every article
  • Online Web exclusive information
  • Photo gallery
  • Breaking news
  • Online classified ads

Already a professionalroofing.net user?

Log in now

User name:



Login help
Click here to have your user name and password emailed to you.

Comments (1) Login to post a comment or rating

Posted by Jallyng on 8/5/2010, User rating 
not ratednot ratednot ratednot ratednot rated
Report Abuse
Thank you for the cautionary advice. In addition to your listed concerns of the testing conditions, I have not seen reports on new or newer shingles installed over de-laminated 3/4" plywood, hail tests on 1x4 or 1x6's, or decking installed vertical on trusses rather than horizontal. There are so many more variables, in addition to these, that could result in shingle failure due to hail... not just hail stone size. Thanks again, I look forward to reading more on this topic.